Why Did Paul Tell Timothy to Drink Wine?
Paul told Timothy to drink a little wine because Timothy was often sick and had been drinking only water. It was health advice from an older friend to a younger one, in a time when wine was one of the few remedies people had for stomach trouble. It wasn’t a command for all Christians, and it wasn’t permission to drink freely.
The verse is short and personal. Reading it in context keeps it from being stretched into something it isn’t.
The verse itself
“(No longer drink only water, but use a little wine for the sake of your stomach and your frequent ailments.)”
Three details matter. Timothy had been drinking “no longer” anything but water, so he’d made a choice to avoid wine. Paul says “a little,” not “as much as you like.” And he gives a reason: Timothy’s stomach and his frequent illnesses.
Why Timothy might have stopped drinking
The letter doesn’t say why Timothy stuck to water. But the rest of 1 Timothy gives clues. Paul had just written that church leaders must not be given to wine (1 Timothy 3:3), and that deacons must not be given to much wine (1 Timothy 3:8). Timothy was leading a church in Ephesus, where some people were already looking for reasons to dismiss him because he was young (1 Timothy 4:12).
Many readers think Timothy refused wine completely to be above reproach. That was an honorable choice. But it seems to have cost him his health, and Paul cared about that.
The verse just before it is telling too.
“Do not be hasty in the laying on of hands, nor take part in the sins of others; keep yourself pure.”
Paul had just told Timothy to keep himself pure. Some scholars think Paul added the note about wine so Timothy wouldn’t take “keep pure” to mean he had to refuse even what he needed for his health.
Wine as medicine in the ancient world
In Paul’s day, there were no pharmacies. Many scholars note that water in cities wasn’t always safe, and that wine was used for upset stomachs and for cleaning wounds. The Good Samaritan poured oil and wine on the injured man (Luke 10:34). Paul’s advice fit the medicine of his time.
That’s an important point for today. Paul was doing what a caring friend does: pointing Timothy to the best health help available. Today, the best health help available is a doctor. If Paul were writing to you, he’d likely tell you to see one.
What this verse doesn’t say
It doesn’t say every Christian should drink. It’s one line to one man about one health problem.
It doesn’t say drinking helps with stress, sleep or sadness. Paul names the stomach and illness, nothing else.
It doesn’t cancel the many warnings about drunkenness elsewhere in Scripture. The same letter that has this verse also sets a high bar for sober leaders.
And it doesn’t apply to someone who can’t stop at “a little.” If alcohol has a hold on you, “a little wine” isn’t a remedy. It’s the problem.
What it does show
The verse shows that the Bible doesn’t treat wine as unclean in itself. Earlier in the same letter, Paul says that everything God created is good when received with thanks (1 Timothy 4:4). It also shows that Paul cared about Timothy’s body, not just his soul. God isn’t indifferent to your health.
If you’re in recovery, that’s the part to hold on to. God cares about your stomach, your sleep, your liver, your mind. Caring for your body today usually means not drinking at all, and getting real medical help.
Safety first. If you drink heavily every day, stopping suddenly can be dangerous. Talk to a doctor before you quit.
If you’ve used this verse to justify drinking
Many people with a drinking problem have quoted this verse at some point. If that’s you, there’s no shame in admitting it. Ask yourself honestly:
- Am I drinking “a little,” or am I drinking until I feel it?
- Am I drinking for my stomach, or for my mood?
- Would a doctor who knew everything about my drinking tell me to keep going?
If those questions sting, that’s useful information. Bring it to God and to someone you trust.
A prayer about your health
“Father, You cared about Timothy’s body, and You care about mine. I’ve told myself drinking helps me, and I’m not sure that’s true anymore. Give me the honesty to see what alcohol is really doing to me. Lead me to the help I need, and thank You that You care about all of me. Amen.”
Talk it through with Jimmy or Sarah — first month free
Jimmy and Sarah are AI sponsors who know the Twelve Steps and the Bible. They'll listen, walk the steps with you, and keep pointing you to real people: a meeting, a sponsor, a church.
Free to download · first month free, no card · adults 18+
After the first month, talking with Jimmy or Sarah needs Plus ($9.99/month or $59.99/year).
For leaders and drinking, see What does the Bible say about pastors drinking? For the whole picture, read What does the Bible say about alcohol?
Common questions
What does 1 Timothy 5:23 mean?
Paul tells Timothy, who seems to have been drinking only water, to take a little wine for his stomach and his frequent illnesses. It's personal health advice from a mentor to a younger friend, given in a world without modern medicine.
Does 1 Timothy 5:23 mean Christians should drink wine?
No. It's a word to one man about his health, not a command to every believer. It does show that the Bible doesn't treat wine as evil in itself. It doesn't make drinking right for someone who can't control it.
Why was Timothy only drinking water?
The letter doesn't say. Many readers think Timothy had chosen not to drink, possibly to set an example or avoid criticism, since church leaders were not to be given to wine. Paul's note suggests that choice was hurting his health.
Talk it through with Jimmy or Sarah — first month free
Jimmy and Sarah are AI sponsors who know the Twelve Steps and the Bible. They'll listen, walk the steps with you, and keep pointing you to real people: a meeting, a sponsor, a church.
Free to download · first month free, no card · adults 18+
After the first month, talking with Jimmy or Sarah needs Plus ($9.99/month or $59.99/year).
Get the daily reading by email
One short reading a day: a verse, a few honest words, one thing to do and a prayer. Unsubscribe any time.
We'll send one email to confirm. We never share your address.